Overweight patients more likely to disagree with their doctors advice on weight loss and lifestyle

Updated: Sep 5

Overweight patients are more inclined to disagree with their health care providers on advice on weight loss and lifestyle, according to researchers from the University Toulouse III Paul Sabatier, Toulouse, France. The findings were reported in the paper, ‘Interaction between patient and general practitioner according to the patient body weight: a cross-sectional survey’, published in Family Practice.

Previous research has shown patients and doctors often have dissimilar attitudes about weight. Patients tend to attribute excess weight to factors that they cannot control (e.g., genetics, hormones), whereas physicians tend to attribute it to behavioural, and thus controllable, factors (e.g., nutrition, physical activity). While many factors contribute to patients' weight and health, these differences in perception of weight could degrade doctor-patient interaction.


This study aimed to analyse whether the interaction between patients and their doctors, as measured by their disagreement on information and advice given during the consultation, varied according to the patient's body mass index.


Twenty-seven general practitioners and 585 patients from three regions in France participated in the quantitative phase of the project in September and October of 2007 and answered questionnaires collecting both general practitioners' and patients' perceptions of information and advice given at the end of the consultation.


The researchers explored differences concerning the patient's and doctor's declarations about actions, information, and advice during the same visit, the patient's health status, and the perceived quality of their relationship.


For example, the questions about weight loss were: "Did your doctor advise you to lose weight during the consultation?" (Answered by patients) and its mirror "Did yo

u advise this patient to lose weight during the consultation?" (Answered by doctors). Differences in answers given by doctors and their patients were used to define disagreement.


Agreement between patients and doctors was weak (20 to 40% agreement) or moderate (40 to 60% agreement) for most of the questions, including questions about actions, information, advice, and patient's health status discussed during the doctor's appointment. Agreement was very weak (less than 20% agreement) for questions about the perceived quality of the patient-doctor relationship.


Researchers also found that there was more doctor-patient disagreement the more overweight the patient was. Disagreement was particularly pronounced for advice given by doctors on weight and lifestyle issues. Compared to patients with a "normal" BMI, overweight patients were more likely to disagree with their doctors regarding advice given on weight loss, advice given on doing more physical activity, and advice about nutrition.

“These disagreements could degrade the quality of patient–physician relationship,” the authors concluded. “Our study provides an opportunity for GPs to reflect on how they communicate with overweight and obese patients, particularly with regard to lifestyle and weight-related advice and interventions taking into account the patient’s representations.”

"An exploration of the patient's representations and difficulties related to weight could be offered by the general practitioners as a basis for discussion and appropriate support," said the study's lead author, Dr Laëtitia Gimenez.