FDA updates potential risks with liquid-filled intragastric balloons
There were no deaths reported in the Orbera and ReShape post-approval studies; however, it should be noted that neither of the studies were powered to detect rare events such as death.
The FDA has provided an update on the potential risks of over-inflation (spontaneous hyperinflation - the spontaneous filling of intragastric balloons with additional air or liquid while inside a patient’s stomach, typically resulting in the need for early device removal), acute pancreatitis and deaths in patients with Orbera and ReShape liquid-filled intragastric balloons used for weight loss in adult patients with obesity.
The FDA first communicated on the potential risk of hyperinflation and acute pancreatitis with liquid-filled intragastric balloons in February 2017. Since then, the FDA provided updates in August 2017 and June 2018 about the potential risk of death with liquid-filled intragastric balloons, and in December 2019 announced the availability of the final data summary for the Reshape balloon post-approval study (PAS). The PAS for the Orbera intragastric balloon has been completed.
The update describes the results from the post-approval studies for hyperinflation and acute pancreatitis for both the Obera and ReShape devices, provides an update on adverse event reports received by the FDA, and provides our latest recommendations to health care providers.
The FDA recommends that health care providers:
Consider the post-approval study results, including specifically hyperinflation and acute pancreatitis, when discussing the risks and benefits of liquid-filled intragastric balloons with patients.
Carefully follow the product labelling which includes more information about possible risks associated with the use of these devices in the US.
The FDA continues to recommend that health care providers:
Instruct patients about the symptoms of potentially life-threatening complications such as balloon deflation, gastrointestinal obstruction, ulceration, and gastric and oesophageal perforation and advise them when to seek medical attention.
Monitor patients closely during the entire duration of treatment with liquid-filled intragastric balloon systems for potential complications, including acute pancreatitis, spontaneous hyperinflation, and other potentially life-threatening complications.
Report any adverse events related to intragastric balloon systems through MedWatch, the FDA Safety Information and Adverse Event Reporting programme.
In 2015, the FDA approved two liquid-filled intragastric balloon systems for use in the US, the Orbera and ReShape intragastric balloon systems. The Orbera Intragastric Balloon System is manufactured by Apollo Endosurgery and the ReShape Integrated Dual Balloon System, previously manufactured by ReShape Medical, was acquired by Apollo Endosurgery in December 2018. In January 2019, Apollo Endosurgery stopped selling and distributing the ReShape intragastric balloon.
As a condition of approval for both the Orbera and ReShape intragastric balloons, the FDA required the manufacturers to conduct a post-approval study assessing their postmarket performance. The FDA's Post-Approval Study Database provides the study protocol parameters for the Orbera post-approval study and ReShape post-approval study. The primary endpoint in both studies was the rate of device- and procedure-related serious adverse events.
The FDA issued the latest update to health care providers to inform them of the final results from the post-approval studies, specifically for hyperinflation and acute pancreatitis. The final data summary for all other post-approval study results can be found on the respective post-approval study webpages for Orbera and ReShape. In addition, the FDA is providing an update on our continued evaluation of reported deaths in patients with Orbera and ReShape liquid-filled intragastric balloons.
In 2016, the FDA approved the Obalon Balloon System, which is a gas-inflated intragastric balloon system unlike Orbera and ReShape, which are liquid-filled. The FDA also required its manufacturer to conduct a post-approval study assessing the postmarket performance of the device. To date, the FDA has not received any reports of death, hyperinflation or acute pancreatitis associated with the Obalon Balloon System in the US. The FDA will continue to monitor the results of the ongoing post-approval studies for the Obalon Balloon System and Obalon Navigation-Touch System, as well as other sources of adverse event reports.
From the Orbera post-approval study, six out of 258 patients (2.3%) experienced balloon hyperinflation. The onset of symptoms ranged from as early as within one week of balloon placement, to 23 weeks after balloon placement. Clinical symptoms included nausea, vomiting and abdominal pain. In four of the six cases, these symptoms prompted the early removal of the balloons. In one patient, the balloon was removed at 24 weeks (six months) after placement due to symptoms. For the remaining event, balloon hyperinflation was found at the time of removal and did not involve any clinical symptoms.
From the ReShape post-approval study, there were no events of hyperinflation reported.
The FDA has received over 200 adverse event reports of hyperinflation worldwide since the 2015 approvals of Orbera and ReShape, with over 99% of those reports received for Orbera. The FDA continues to work with Apollo Endosurgery to evaluate the root cause of hyperinflation with the Orbera intragastric balloon, as well as potential mitigation strategies. The FDA wants to ensure that you are aware of the incidence of this potential complication as observed in the post-approval studies.
Acute pancreatitis may develop in patients with liquid-filled intragastric balloons. Although the precise pathophysiology is unknown, the mechanism could be related to pressure from the balloon and distended stomach causing direct injury to the pancreatic parenchyma, compression of the pancreatic duct, and/or indirect pancreatic injury through duodenal obstruction.
From the Orbera post-approval study, there were no events of acute pancreatitis reported.
From the ReShape post-approval study, two out of 159 patients (1.3%) had diagnosed acute pancreatitis. The onset of symptoms occurred at 3 days and two weeks after balloon placement, respectively. Clinical symptoms included nausea, vomiting, and abdominal pain. In both cases, the balloon was removed early.
The FDA has received nearly 30 adverse event reports of acute pancreatitis worldwide since the 2015 approvals of Orbera and ReShape, with over two-thirds of those reports received for Orbera. Although the focus of this communication is to highlight the adverse events observed in the post-approval studies for liquid-filled balloons, the FDA is aware of published cases of pancreatitis with air-filled intragastric balloons in patients outside of the US. The FDA will continue to work with the manufacturers of all available intragastric balloons in the US. to monitor this potential complication.
There were no deaths reported in the Orbera and ReShape post-approval studies; however, it should be noted that neither of the studies were powered to detect rare events such as death. Additionally, there were no events of gastric or oesophageal perforation reported in either study.
Since the last update in June 2018, the FDA has received reports of one death in the US associated with the Orbera device, four deaths outside of the US associated with the Orbera device and one death outside of the US reported from the literature for the Orbera device. Of these, four deaths, including one in the US, occurred following gastric perforation, one day to six months after balloon placement. One reported death involved a patient outside the US who died one day after balloon placement; however, the root cause and device relatedness of the death is not known. One death, outside of the US was reported from the literature as a case of misdiagnosed Wernicke-Korsakoff Syndrome (Wernicke-Korsakoff syndrome is a neurodegenerative disorder resulting from a vitamin B1 deficiency) after intragastric balloon therapy.
Since the approvals of Orbera and ReShape, the FDA has received reports for a total of 18 deaths that occurred worldwide. Ten of these 18 deaths occurred outside of the US. The remaining eight deaths occurred in the US (five with Orbera and three with ReShape).
Additional clinical descriptions are as follows:
Occurred following gastric perforation (n=3)
Occurred following oesophageal perforation (n=1)
Occurred within a few days of balloon placement, but the root cause of death is unknown and therefore the FDA is unable to definitively attribute the death to the balloon therapy (i.e. unanticipated death) (n=2)
Occurred following complications from pulmonary embolism after balloon placement (n=2)
The FDA will continue to monitor the safety of liquid-filled intragastric balloons by working with manufacturers to monitor and evaluate death reports, assess possible risk factors and mitigations, and ensure that the products' labelling addresses this risk. The agency will continue to work with Apollo Endosurgery to ensure that the Orbera product labelling includes the post-approval study findings.
Since 2017, the FDA has worked with the manufacturers of all available intragastric balloons in the U.S. (liquid-filled and gas-filled) to update their labelling with more information about possible risks associated with use of their device in the US including death, acute pancreatitis, and hyperinflation. We will continue to ensure that the products' labelling address these risks, as well as other potentially life-threatening complications.
The FDA will continue to keep health care providers and the public informed if new or additional information becomes available.